„My Path“ after twenty years
After the faith fades, the ritual remains.
We still carry stones — not for victory,
but to remember our past goals.
— ChatGPT, mimicking a contemporary
Twenty-two years ago, a college fresher penned an essay titled My
Path. She began with a modest line: ‹I don’t consider myself a
winner. I am just an ordinary person who keeps growing and
thinking.›
Then: The age of Ciang and Qu
She, Ciang Yaucuang in the conventional romanization of this blog,
was anything but ordinary. Outsmarting her peers at a high achieving
school, Ciang enrolled in School of Life Sciences, Peking University in
2003, then a holy grail for the academically gifted. Born in both a good
time and a hard time for her homeland, when people suffered from
pounding and isolation, and skeptics of knowledge treking the wild,
Ciang can not be deduced to a blessed girl or a persistant figure from
Confucian fable. Though not the first obtaining media attention, Ciang
is where the integration of giftedness and presentation has taken on its
original form. ‹Accept knowledge with a heartfelt and humble love,› she
wrote, ‹and try to understand its beauty.› Ciang continued with words
adequately glorious for an adolescent:
Mathematics and physics have concise definitions, rigorous proofs,
ingenious reasoning, and countless perfect rules and truths. To carve a
regular hexagonal cross-section into a cube is, for me, a sheer delight
for no reason — it is symmetrical, thus perfect. Deriving the same
solution respectively through the theorem of momentum and the
conservation of mechanical energy is also a pleasure for no reason —
they outline truth from aspect to aspect, allowing me to discern the
contours. Chemistry and biology are filled with strange phenomena,
wondrous legends, mysterious substances, and countless reflections on
life. When you hold the sky-blue crystals of copper sulphate in your
palm, would you not handle them with the utmost care? As if admiring a
delicate, fragile work of art. When you trace the shadow of a paramecium
under the microscope, would you not feel elated? As if encountering one
of the Creator’s miracles.
Eighteen-year-old Ciang casts pebbles into the mist, much like one
searching for paramecia under a microscope. Between the beauty of
knowledge, and the homily of ideal life, she finds solace only in her
own company.
Was that really love that Ciang felt? A cultural reductionist will
deem everything ritual; more lowbrow, one who recognises that
examinations are merely lantern riddles disguised as academic subjects
is adequate to respond. Ciang seemed to lean onto the implausible
statement, that she was repulsing the skeptics, like a cartoon heroine,
only by conformance and heartfelt love.
Ciang was not alone. Her story, including how she have earned titles
including ‹top ten campus beauties› and ‹classroom runway show›, was peddled by Qu Qieptau, a fellow
Life Sciences student. His bestselling book, adequately named
Secret: Tricks of Geniuses from Peking University, mixed
tactical advice with mythic storytelling. The narrative method proudly
named „white cut chicken essay“ by Qu entails Ciang-like figures that
also fits in The Onion: 30,000-word English vocabularies,
unbeatable rhetorics, élite physical stamina. The 1980s-style ebullient
stories softened the monotony of time management charts and review
schedules. Readers did not just want to succeed. They wanted to succeed
like that.
It has been another decade when I came across Qu’s book.
When Qoo Iaw Dang Heocbah, a student-run screen time manager
and forum whose name translates to „I want to be a top student“ launched
in 2013, my primary school classmates and I dismissed the proactive
phone lock as a tedious joke. By middle school when I diverged from dear
Muqliong and paid allegiance to Heocbah, the platform had
become a socialing paradise of timers, productivity logs, and taglines
inherited from Qu’s chapters.
Phone locking is just locking. BBS forums have fallen behind the
times even then. Still, Heocbah held or at least witnessed
a revolutionary edge: for the first time, individual striving gained a
collective template. We buried our heads in screens and papers, feigning
deafness to the buzzing local accents behind us, labouring in a utopia
where effort guaranteed reward — never considering the mechanisation
inherent in it all. Qu went further in his sequel, The Radish
Project, declaring that gyakushū,
„to turn defeat into victory“ (a Japanese-derived teen slang), requires
no willpower.
It was there that I met my peers, earnest, adorable, anxious, betting
Pascal’s wager to become another Ciang. But even then, there was a
divide between the reality and the ideal. I was distracted, not by video
games or romantic novels frequently accused by Qu, Heocbah, and
anonymous parents. I was distracted by my own mind — by books that were
not taught, by thoughts that did not fit into the upcoming exam. I was
seen as learning excessively, a beautiful misunderstanding. I
unconsciously treated textbooks as my very game, labelled five-star
generals on practice problems, and tracked performance in spreadsheets,
simply because across the Southern Mountain someone did the same.
Ciang and her succeessors writing by Wèimíng Lake remained our
reference point, as a disguise as if we could really perceive the true
love of endeavour notwithstanding any outcome. Ciang is overly correct:
‹We learn for cultivation and sublimation of our own. Speak not about
universities, jobs, or material security. Everything learnt will act on
your body and mind, in the subtle change in your state of being.›
Now: Fragmented goals and
aesthetics
A stoic, a pen, a lit-up room, a miracle. The tale of Ciang submerged
into the élite school narrative that was seen eternally outmoded, the
snow of yesteryear that itself last for decades. But people did tow the
culture to somewhere else. In another decade, modern Ciang-ites, still
stoic figures though, emerged from the ring lights.
As I coveted the bright lights of Heocbah, a sharp rise of
commercialization happened within the education culture. Top-notched
peers in the walls of vines were invited into live studios, one of whom
has named her presentation after the famous quote by Siegfried Sassoon:
In me the tiger sniffs the rose.
In late Heocbah dynasty, „white fox“ timidly walked into an
interview of enrollment and managed to be an alumna of Ciang. She was
holding a novel in hand, her opponents mostly stacks of academic papers.
It was less symbolic than expected, no more than the pale elapse of time
— literature as a curated interest and a rehearsed dissent was traced
back to the turn of the century. Rather, trivially as one believes for a
novelist, the review/recurrence post has unveiled so deeply in her
delicate heart.
Heocbah did not see the
coming spring. In modern words, it was a refugee
influx.
REDnote
and TikTok were on rise, replacing niche online communities with
un-windproof screens. Not only students, but also working professionals
in their twenties or early thirties, graduated from Ciang’s legacy.
„Succeeded“ following the verbal tradition — top universities, envied
jobs, often in competitive cities — they pledged loyalty to their
teenage selves with skincare, hiking, and mandolin. They used to mouth
their love of biology or literature. Now, in place of „multifaceted
life“ cliché, they simply say „because it’s there“, and seemingly that
should always be.
Change from campus to workplace explain little. Those influencers
never claim themselves influencers. They are, though outstanding, still
normal. Audaciously though, they blurred the essense of their work and
fatigue, as solely ornament and „proofs of existence“ of a larger
picture. An axiomatic universality. An unexpected perfect portrait (they
are magically endowed with gorgeous figures), a sunlight-shed balcony,
or a dim corner in a recent concert. Zooming out, we see as if the tales
of white foxes were silently piled.
A generation who entered the examination hall together now bid of
identity maintenance. Structure collapsing as their rites of passage —
declining material security, high-rising house prices, algorithm-driven
self-exposure, and indefinitely suspeneded realization of endowment —
they clutched at the straw. I am still on the path. I deserve the
path. Though I was never Ciang, I am not lost. Makeup, lo-fi beats,
carefully placed camera, fragile but persistent self-ritual — justifying
the past with aesthetics.
Remaining ritual and
changing course
Across the divide of twenty years a dedicate tension lies between the
continuity of form and the erosion of substance. Ciang’s generation
recited I love learning as doctrine, while present-day
Ciang-ites still whisper its echoes in softened tone. Paper and pencils
are replaced by Obsidian, Tiger Balm by lipstick, but the posture of
devotion remains intact.
But does that make it the same thing?
The rituals have survived: early rising, colour-coded schedules, even
the meticulous highlighting of biology textbooks. Yet the centre of
gravity has shifted. The beauty of paramecium is irrevalant. Action
itself is beauty; if it is not, let it be. Today it might be CFA
vocabulary or Duolingo challenge; tomorrow, a dance challenge or a
journaling format. Attempt has become aesthetic, portable, perhaps
goal-agnostic.
Teenage Ciang disbelieved the cynicism that education was futile, nor
did she subscribe to the complimental notion that higher qualifications
= brighter future. The mindset of My Path, though naïve, does
belong to a young top student. Now, the generation believe just enough
to keep going, but not enough to change. Ciang’s alumni sitting by
Wèimíng Lake, instead of composing another My Path, are moaning
their ephemeral careers like anyone else.
Trends are macroeconomical. Individuals experience a fragment of
history, that was seen as their very entirety. Yes, the twenty years
have witnessed education
being nullified. Commencement speech drifted from honour to satire.
That is, though, only the evident part of an iceberg. In an credited
extracurricular event, an environmental science professor whom I met for
only this time raised a small heavy book and said,
This is the textbook for a course I sitted in America. I always hope
you, with all the background knowledge, assail the most challenging
courses for your last semester, but I know, you will bury yourselves in
examinations and interviews!
When I was idling at high school and read My Path with my
father, I already held the modern view. That a cube has a regular
hexagonal cross-section, that the theorem of momentum and the
conservation of mechanical energy are equivalent expressions — isn’t
this the most trifle fact imaginable? I would rather ponder how to
derive the Poisson spot.
Even mythic heroes themselved are not immune from the silent trend.
Ciang’s rumoured move from biology to consultancy reflected a delicate
drift, that adaptability and vibe begin to weigh more than intellectual
integrity for the working aged generation. We are informed to
be speedrunners.
The very cultural mechanism that once facilitated intellectual
progress is now perpetuating self-doubt and fragmented ambition. There
is no true self-cultivation in a system-overwhelming world. Students who
dreamt to become Ciang now find themselves staying on a path, but
without a destination. They persist in the rituals without conviction.
The generational subculture has mutated from a meritocratic ladder to a
mosaic of survival strategies. Some still aim at
excellence. Others aim at visibility. Most aim, tacitly, at dignity.
The path is no longer important. We care more about stories we can
still convince ourselves of.
That story has become quieter. More reflexive. Less triumphant. But
it still exists. In every person who wakes up to an alarm they set the
night before. In every carefully annotated Kindle passage. In every
mundane step taken not out of clarity, but hoping that clarity might
someday return.
Interlude
A girl with flashcards
’tis 11:47 pm, and she is reviewing English flashcards at the kitchen
table.
The soft hum of the refrigerator marks time more faithfully than her
smartwatch. On the table: half a cup of cold barley tea, a cracked iPad,
a planner open to a colour-coded page stated
KEEP GOING.
She is twenty-eight now. Consultant, or analyst — hard to explain the
job to her parents, and harder to explain to herself. The office is
quiet, the work ambiguous, the pay enough.
She still uses the same vocabulary app from high school. The
interface has changed, but the word lists are eerily familiar.
Recalcitrant. Ephemeral. Nonplussed. She whispers them under
her breath, like old friends at a reunion where no one is sure who aged
better.
Somewhere in another apartment, maybe three stations away, a younger
girl is posting a video: Study With Me, 10 pm to 2 am, Pomodoro Timer.
The same markers. The same tilt of the lamp. The same desperate
tenderness toward structure.
The woman at the table thinks she sees herself in that girl. She
wants to warn her, or maybe just apologise. But more honestly, she
envies her: the clarity, the flame, the unbroken line between effort and
meaning. That line is now bleak from her life. She still does the
things. She still counts the minutes, highlights the sentences, chooses
the right filter. But the sense of destiny is gone.
Once, she believed that hard work led somewhere. That if you threw
enough stones, Goliath would fall.
Now she throws them for the sound they make.
A boy on the rooftop
He was never good at exams. Not bad, just… not good.
While others colour-coded their notebooks, he drew maps of imaginary
cities in the margins. He preferred long walks to past-paper drills, and
often fell asleep in the library with a book that had nothing to do with
the curriculum. He never hated school, instead, only not found the
urgency that others seemed to carry like oxygen tanks.
He remembers watching the top scorers walk past, neat uniforms and
faster footsteps, laughter that sounded rehearsed. They were always
reviewing something, always prepared for a eureca moment. He respected
them, or in better wording, resented them. But mostly, he felt like he
was out of the story.
Now, years later, he works as a technician for a small company that
fixes air conditioning systems. An honest work. In summer, his shirt
clings to his back by 10 am; in winter, his hands are always slightly
chapped. There is a calmness to it, a dignity in being useful. No one
asks for grades. No one discusses paramecia.
But some nights, when he finishes late, he climbs onto the roof of a
client’s building. Bathing in the wind, he watches lattices of glowing
windows. Some flicker with PowerPoint slides. Some with livestreamed
lectures. Some, probably, with videos of young people mouthing
motivational slogans into ring lights.
He wonders what would have happened if he had chased Ciang’s path.
Would it have broken him? Or saved him? He doesn’t know. But he suspects
that some of those windows belong to people who feel the same, unsure if
they are ahead or behind, unsure what was supposed to happen.
So he stands there a while. Not chasing anything. Not regretting
much. Just letting the city breathe.
A path, or a reason to
proceed
Ciang’s word path, after twenty years of sedimentation, has
become weary and mystical. The Ciang of 2003 embodied the aspirational
clarity of a generation who believed, or at least performed belief, that
excellence would carry them forward. But what we have witnessed over two
decades is not a collapse of that vision, nor an all-around revolution,
but something more ambiguous: a diffusion.
A path of Ciang’s own become that of a generation. Some study with
monk-like discipline. Some excel in multiple fields. But increasingly,
they do so under different lights. While once the goal was entrance into
a world of seriousness and sublimity, student-influencers today are
generalists in excellence, attempting to re-tie the sailor’s knot by
voice, poise, and adaptability.
Twenty years on, the board of Ciang in Tiēbā, once flooding the
„campus beauty“ discussion, has long faded. Some persist in quietly
refuting rumours, insisting she continues her neuroscience
research. Frankly, for a scholar, ResearchGate suffices — it was the
last lesson from Ciang, that life is not simply „being oneself“. Even if
we are Ciang, a few research papers are merely formalities. Passion is a
joke in academic marathon. The sense of independence is insuffice,
sentimental, and often a condolence of self-exploitation. We seek not to
settle and conform. We thirst for answers to the reality, not the scant
answer scribbled on yellowed exam papers. Even if we have forgotten what
we want.
The path ahead has grown hazy. The aura remains, illuminating what
the passion made us look like. The tragedy is not that the path is gone.
The tragedy, if any, is that we expected a path at all. We believed we
are ordained to follow the path. In reality, what we inherited was an
illusion of roadposts, a set of postures, and a language for struggle
that outlives its predestinated purpose. From a path seemingly forged by
one individual two decades ago, to the flame a few students raised like
a manga hero a decade past, to the silent collective subconscious of
today.
But maybe, that is appropriate.
We skillfully load the stones and bow our bodies, which does not have
to be a story of failure, but of cultural memory. We are doing something
we do not fully understand. A form of survival, a sit-in protest, or
even the herald of another era.
So this is not a eulogy for Ciang-ites, nor for the age of textbooks
and flashcards. It is an acknowledgment that the path never really
existed the way we thought. In the end of the day, across the scattered
stones and mismatched stories, something still tries to walk.
The end
Above is the full text. Click to unfold further discussions.
It is a long overdue idea ultimately written prior to the Higher
Education Entrance Examination in 2025.
I do feel the style of writing expulsively internetty, but I can do
nothing. I just go through some opinions for the rest of the page.
‹Don’t you know all the traumata?›
I wish I have not erroneously implied that current education culture
is always softened or aestheticised. From time to time, it remains
oppresive. And this is commonly what you expect to read on the internet,
for bad news travels fast. But there is no reason to polarise either
way.
Gorgeous faces also travel fast. Ciang is herself an influencer,
sharing most of the factors intended for today’s counterparts. Someone
may ask, did the transition in this post happen only between twenty
years? Did it applied as well between Ciang, writing My Path,
and her readers? Or Ciang and her classmates failed to admit to Peking
University? The answer is yes. It takes time however, if not twenty
years, to verify that the phenomenon appearing to be personal gee-whiz
is a trauma of generation.
After all, I am not criticising the system. I am overwhelmed with the
grief, however, that our whole generation still carries stones in hand,
polishing into symbolism in the disastrous years, because of a miracle
that never happened.
‹Relationship always matters.›
Thanks to William Goodspeed for this argument. The great talker may
be surprised that flashcard girl and rooftop boy are thinking alone.
Emotional connection is key to wellness, of course. But the insertion of
survivalist perspective is exactly what followers of Ciang have done,
consummately.
By highlighting a reductionist value to people around, Goodspeed
implies that publishment of academic papers or participation in a
gamechanging product is itself not valuable. This is brilliant. The
grand narrative have collapsed to a level that on REDnote there are
comments reading ‹I believed [the employer] have forged the photos of
such a handsome programmer to promote their automatic driving
business›.
What I differ from Goodspeed is that I presume that people will be
more lonely under this collapse.
Finally, in a few days, some of my friends will attend the
tough exam. Good luck.